Author Archives: James J Heaney

Why Liberals Lie to Themselves about the Contraceptive Mandate

I’ve noticed that liberal sources (not to mention Facebook friends) have consistently made the mistake of calling the Church’s refusal to pay for employees’ contraceptive drugs a “denial” or a “deprivation” or an “attack on women’s rights.”  This is, of … Continue reading

Posted in Mere Opinion | 136 Comments

A Back-and-Forth on the Contraceptive Mandate

From a conversation (names and identifying information removed): If the Catholic Church wants to contemplate something that is far more relevant, perhaps they should consider the irony of their outrage against the Obama administration for originally requiring them to provide … Continue reading

Posted in In Conversation, Law | 1,537 Comments

Is Marriage the Right Battle? Are We Fighting it Right?

From a reader: Okay, question.  No-fault divorce, contraception, and abortion have all been declared constitutional in the U.S. Do we really have a legal leg to stand on then on the marriage amendment?  If marriage is defined (as it really … Continue reading

Posted in Law, Marriage, Mere Opinion | 216 Comments

Justice Ginsburg Should Resign

She should resign.  She doesn’t have to.  There’s no legal or moral obligation for her to do so.  But I don’t believe it is appropriate or wise to have someone maintain final interpretive authority over the Constitution when she doesn’t … Continue reading

Posted in Law, Mere Opinion | 218 Comments

Romney: Still a Second-Rate Candidate

Gov. Romney’s entire campaign pitch is, “Sure, I’m boring, vacuous, and not particularly conservative, but I have business experience that will appeal to independents, and I’m electable, so I can win in November.” News flash: Now that independent voters have gotten to … Continue reading

Posted in Analysis, Horse Race, Pith | 2,052 Comments

REACTION: Personally Opposed, but Sleeping with the Enemy

I am rather a fan of Dr. Heaney, who has a new piece in The Public Discourse today.  Money quote: Those in favor of such an expansive version of liberty, and thus an expansive version of marriage and sexuality, seem … Continue reading

Posted in Reads & Reactions | 215 Comments

The Real Lesson of the Komen Kerfuffle

As I argued in my last post, abortionists and their supporters have never faced the reality pro-lifers have lived for forty years: there has never been a serious attack on their legitimacy.  What we learned today is that the dedicated supporters of legal … Continue reading

Posted in Pith | 826 Comments

Komen vs. Planned Parenthood: A Win-Win-Win

Both sides are declaring victory in the landmark case Susan G. Komen for the Cure vs. Planned Parenthood of America.  Well and good.  Both sides won.  Pro-lifers hold the battlefield: Komen is never going to give money to Planned Parenthood again … Continue reading

Posted in Mere Opinion | 131 Comments

Re: Were Early Republicans “Conservative”?

From a Facebook discussion I’m having: How are you defining “conservative,” James? I’ve done a lot of reading on the 19th Century, and the early Republican Party has always seemed mighty liberal to me. You know, “Radical” Republicans, valuing civil … Continue reading

Posted in Mere Opinion, Reads & Reactions | 88 Comments

READS: The Definitive Secular Gay Marriage Discussion

I am sick to the teeth of reposting this every few weeks, so I am going to put it here now that I have a blog and just link to it. In early 2011, Robert P. George, a prominent social … Continue reading

Posted in Reads & Reactions | 1 Comment